Movie Name: I Don't Understand You
Year of Release: 2024
Director: David Joseph Craig, Brian Crano
Starring: Andrew Rannells, Nick Kroll, Morgan Spector, Eleonora Romandini, Nunzia Schiano, Amanda Seyfried, Paolo Romano, Cecilia Dazzi, Leonardo Verni
Score out of ten (whole numbers only): 4
Watch it on Hulu
Year of Release: 2024
Director: David Joseph Craig, Brian Crano
Starring: Andrew Rannells, Nick Kroll, Morgan Spector, Eleonora Romandini, Nunzia Schiano, Amanda Seyfried, Paolo Romano, Cecilia Dazzi, Leonardo Verni
Score out of ten (whole numbers only): 4
Watch it on Hulu
Synopsis and Review
"I Don't Understand You" is the feature directorial debut of the directing team of David Joseph Craig and Brian Crano (though Brian Crano has a few directorial endeavors of his own as part of his filmography). The film follows the story of a married couple, Cole and Dom, who live in the Los Angeles area, and who are trying to go through with an adoption process for their first child. They have been previously scammed, so they're going into this next process with some apprehension. They are also on their way to Italy to celebrate their 10 year anniversary. They quickly connect with the birth mother, a woman by the name of Candace, who assures them that their application was the one that touched her the most. While in Italy, they connect with Daniele, an old friend of Dom's father, who has arranged for them to have a wonderful meal with a celebrated and somewhat reclusive restaurant owner. They eventually make their way to the remote locale, getting lost in the process, and eventually meet the elderly Zia Luciana, who is the cook and also used to own the restaurant. While the couple doesn't understand a word she's saying, she invites them to sit, and starts serving them a freshly baked pizza and wine. Cole wants to leave the place as soon as possible, but as they're trying to get their phone in order to secure a way back to the hotel, the power goes out. There's some chaos and Cole accidentally knocks Zia down a flight of stairs. They're horrified when they can't catch a pulse, and even more so when they try CPR on her, and hear bones cracking. They decide to bring Zia upstairs to the dining area, and hide her under the table. Unexpectedly Massimo, Zia's son, arrives with both their rental car, and also an insistent desire for them to stay and eat more with the family.
"I Don't Understand You" is a film that tries to be quite a few different things but that sadly fails to find the right tone and direction in which it wants to go. One of the aspects of the narrative is the quite emotional journey of a gay couple on their path to fatherhood, with their fears and anxieties pertaining to be parents and even more so, avoiding falling into the trap of another expensive scam. The other aspect of the narrative is the dark and bloody comedy that appears midway during the film, one that takes the feature in a very different direction, trying to elicit more comedy due to the over-the-top situation in which the characters find themselves. While the first aspect of the narrative is successful, particularly the relationship between the couple which feels vividly illustrated, the second aspect feels dastardly put together. The writing and directing duo fail to go all in with the dark and macabre tone they introduce, for fear of possibly alienating the audiences from the ground they have built humanizing that lovely gay couple. While the filmmakers don't necessarily need to adopt an Eli Roth approach to the gore and killing that ensues, the film feels rather anemic, and not fully embracing of the premise that they just introduced. The filmmakers commit a cardinal mistake in situations such as these: they don't relish the situation they just created, opting instead to illustrate these morally corrupt individuals as people with good intentions, that have done some terrible things, but that ultimately meant well, and therefore have the right to a happy ending. The narrative should have been far more visceral, committed, and funnier, since this film presents itself as a comedy that doesn't have many laughs. The cast is a bit all over the place, but Nick Kroll and Andrew Rannells have great chemistry. The production team is polished, in particular the cinematography from Lowell A. Meyer. It's not an unwatchable film, it's just not a particularly memorable one.





