Movie Name: Mother and Child
Year of Release: 2009
Director: Rodrigo Garcia
Starring: Naomi Watts, Annette Bening, Kerry Washington, Samuel L. Jackson, Eileen Ryan, David Ramsey, Cherry Jones, Jimmy Smits, Elpidia Carrillo, David Morse, Marc Blucas, Carla Gallo, S. Epatha Merkerson, Michael Warren, Shareeka Epps, Amy Brenneman, Elizabeth Peña, Britt Robertson, LisaGay Hamilton,
Score out of ten (whole numbers only): 7
Watch it on Amazon
Year of Release: 2009
Director: Rodrigo Garcia
Starring: Naomi Watts, Annette Bening, Kerry Washington, Samuel L. Jackson, Eileen Ryan, David Ramsey, Cherry Jones, Jimmy Smits, Elpidia Carrillo, David Morse, Marc Blucas, Carla Gallo, S. Epatha Merkerson, Michael Warren, Shareeka Epps, Amy Brenneman, Elizabeth Peña, Britt Robertson, LisaGay Hamilton,
Score out of ten (whole numbers only): 7
Watch it on Amazon
Synopsis and Review
Following the release of "Nine Lives", writer/director Rodrigo Garcia returned to prestige television, directing episodes of "Big Love" and "In Treatment", before tackling the Anne Hathaway vehicle "Passengers", which was met with tepid reviews. He quickly bounced back with "Mother and Child" a film he wrote and directed, and that much like his more personal films, "Nine Lives" and "Things You Can Tell Just By Looking at Her", are comprised of multiple vignettes, some of which intersect with each other. The film introduces us to Karen, a nurse whom we initially witness as a teenager, having her first sexual experience, which results in a pregnancy and a child, who is given for adoption. Now in her late 40s, Karen takes care of her mother, and carries with her the notion her young daughter is somewhere out there without knowing that she's still around and without understanding of why she was given for adoption. As it turns out, this young woman turns out to be Elizabeth, a highly skilled, ambitious, and with no emotional ties to anyone lawyer, who embarks on a new job with a high prestige law firm owned by Paul, a widower, in the LA area. Elizabeth and Paul have a lot of chemistry, and while Elizabeth never ties herself to anyone, following a traumatic childhood which saw her living in foster homes, and never being cherished as part of a loving family, they eventually start a romantic relationship. Elizabeth however, and owning to her fear of emotional intimacy in any relationship, also starts a casual sexual tryst with her neighbor, who is married and is expecting a child with his wife. Another woman that is part of this narrative is Lucy, who after years of trying to get pregnant with her husband Joseph, have both decided to embark on the adoption path. While they seem to be equally invested, and even start the process of meeting a young woman who is about to give birth, Joseph is having second thoughts. Elizabeth's perfectly structured life suffers an unexpected derailment when she discovers she's pregnant, even though she has had a procedure when she was younger to prevent that from ever happening. She quickly leaves Paul's firm, cuts ties with everyone, and embarks on a journey of her own to have the child.
"Mother and Child" is, of all vignette inspired films that dominated the first part of Rodrigo Garcia's career, the most interesting feature of all three. While the film, which unlike the first two didn't premiere at the Sundance Film Festival, but instead premiered at the Toronto Film Festival, has indeed multiple storylines all of which eventually intersect with each other, and have at their core central female characters, this is the one feature where these characters act, behave, and interact as fully realized individuals. Elizabeth, Karen, Lucy, all of them are impacted by motherhood, they all experience it at different times in their lives, and motherhood has very different impacts in what their subsequent life journey actually is. While Karen lives shackled to a decision that was forced upon her to give her baby up for adoption, something that has hardened her to a certain extent, Elizabeth on the other hand, has created an emotional wall which prevents anyone from ever knowing her and even truly loving her. Lucy lives with the eternal longing of being a mother, and while she's rather immature to realize what that implies, she also stops at nothing to pursue it, even if that sacrifices her marital relationship. These vignettes are far more entwined with each other than any of Mr. Garcia's prior films, and there are some traces of Alan Ball's "Six Feet Under" in this narrative, but the superb work of the cast elevates this narrative beyond what might suggest something very trivial. Naomi Watts, Annette Bening, Samuel L. Jackson, Eileen Ryan, Shareeka Epps, and Britt Robertson, all create indelible characters, with Ms. Watts and Mr. Jackson in particular having great chemistry with each other, therefore creating a very believable relationship, even if it turns out to be a brief one. It's a film that allows these characters to be flawed, to be multi-faceted, and ultimately, that allows them to grow during the duration of the narrative. The production team is solid, including Edward Shearmur's score, Xavier Perez Grobet's cinematography, and Christopher Tandon's subtle production design. It's a solid, revelatory film, from a talented storyteller.














