Year of Release: 2025
Director: Clint Bentley
Starring: Joel Edgerton, Felicity Jones, William H. Macy, Kerry Condon, John Diehl, Clifton Collins Jr., Paul Schneider, Will Patton, Nathaniel Arcand, Eric Ray Anderson, Beau Charles
Score out of ten (whole numbers only): 7
Watch it on Netflix
Synopsis and Review
"Train Dreams" is Clint Bentley's sophomore directorial endeavor, following his well received "Jockey". It's an adaptation of the novella by Denis Johnson, adapted by Bentley and his creative partner Greg Kwedar. The film follows the narrative of Robert Grainier, born in the late 1800s, who as an adult makes a living as a logger and railroad worker in the Idaho area. Robert stays mostly to himself, though he observes how other construction workers go about their lives and how they interact with each other. He eventually meets Gladys Olding, whom he falls in love with, and they both marry and build a log cabin near the Moyie River. They have a daughter whom they name Kate. Robert stays away from his family for months at a time, since he goes where work is available, and that means leaving his loved ones behind. As Kate keeps growing up, he feels that he is missing out on what matters the most to him, Gladys and Kate. They discuss scenarios that will enable him to make an income and stay closer to home, something that is a challenge particularly with the wrecked economy from post-World War I. However upon returning from his last contract as a logger, Robert is crushed to witness his family's log cabin destroyed in a wildfire, with Gladys and Kate nowhere in sight. Robert is desperate and keeps sleeping on the site and waiting for something to happen, raising the worries of his friend Ignatius Jack. He eventually rebuilds the cabin and goes back to logging but soon realizes there's new ways of working in the field, and that he is out of place. He keeps walking through the woods in the hopes he can somehow connect or feel the spirits of his wife and daughter.
"Train Dreams" immediately brings to mind the work of Terrence Malick. The combination of a certain aesthetic, with this quasi philosophical and introspective stance, and voice-over/narration, are very indebted to the point of view Terrence Malick has created with some of his most well known features (including "The Thin Red Line" and "The Tree of Life"). However and what is interesting about Mr. Bentley's perspective, and how he has carved his own point of view with this feature, is the fact that he grounds the existence of his lead character in something more realistic and not so random as is typically the case with Mr. Malick's more recent filmic endeavors. There's nothing particularly self-indulgent about this film, quite the contrary: the writer/director manages to breathe life into the existence of Robert, making it feel authentic, even as he fails to overcome the pain of the loss of the life he was building with his wife, and how he eventually realizes just how distant from modern life he has become. He is portrayed as someone not entirely integrated with how most people live their lives, and he only truly blossoms when he discovers and embraces Gladys' love. It's ultimately a film that illustrates a quiet life, at a time when that was still possible to be lived, when all cruelty and brutality were visceral and violent, at times unavoidable, where people lived for shared experiences and not necessarily for grandiose gestures. It is a film that does bring to life another time, with characters that feel lived in, and with enough color to make them memorable. The cast is fantastic, particularly Joel Edgerton, Felicity Jones, William H. Macy, Kerry Condon, and the wonderful narration of Will Patton. The production team is equally impeccable, particularly Adolpho Veloso's cinematography, Bryce Dessner's score (and the beautiful song he and Nick Cave have created), and Alexandra Schaller's production design. It may not be for everyone's taste, but there's something quite arresting that stays with you after watching this film, even if it does feel a bit too much Terrence Malick derivative. Worth watching.
0 comments:
Post a Comment